California HealthCare Foundation – Supporting ideas and innovations to improve health care for all Californians.

All Over the Map: Elective Procedure Rates in California Vary Widely

For patients contemplating elective procedures, where they live matters. This CHCF research finds practice patterns for certain surgeries and other procedures vary dramatically from place to place.

September 2011

This interactive map presents elective surgery and other procedure rates across California relative to the state averages and shows widely varying rates in spite of data adjustments for disease prevalence and other factors. The research findings are presented in multiple formats below the map.


To view this page ensure that Adobe Flash Player version 10.0.0 or greater is installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Some examples from the data (click each item to see it in the map above):

While some geographic variation in surgical rates is expected due to differences in the prevalence of disease, note the authors, much of the variation seen in California cannot be explained by illness rates. The authors noted that for elective procedures, a patient's own values and willingness to accept uncertainty in outcomes should be considered alongside the clinician's recommendations.

The data include Medicare patients as well as younger populations enrolled in commercial plans, Medicaid, or who are uninsured. The consistency of results across all payers makes this a significant contribution to the literature documenting regional variation.

Available below are these Document Downloads:

  • A summary discussing key factors in medical variation research and the important role that patient input can play in treatment decisions.
  • Seven reports ("Close-Ups") providing detailed data on the 13 procedures examined here.
  • A spreadsheet showing related data on prevalence of heart attacks, a proxy for severe cardiac disease, in California.