California Survey Finds Strong Support for Behavioral Health Benefits

Since passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), the US has seen a dramatic expansion of insurance coverage for mental health and substance use disorder treatment. The health law sparked broader access to these behavioral health services both by giving states the ability to expand Medicaid coverage to more adults with low incomes, and by giving teeth to existing mental health parity laws. Today, meaningful coverage of mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) is real for millions more people.

Californians recognize the value of this coverage. In a statewide Berkeley IGS poll supported by CHCF and released today, three in four respondents said that mental health and SUD treatment not only can help people live healthy and productive lives, but that it is “very important” for insurance plans to cover this treatment. Support for coverage of behavioral health care crosses all demographic and regional subgroups, including all ethnic groups and age brackets. It has bipartisan support as well, with 59% of Republicans and 86% of Democrats telling interviewers such coverage is “very important.”

Percentage of Californians who say insurance coverage for behavioral health conditions is important, by region

Medicaid is the single biggest payer for mental health treatment and is playing a much larger role in covering substance use disorder treatment. In California, of the approximately 4 million people in the Medi-Cal expansion group, an estimated 450,000 have a substance use disorder. The American Health Care Act (AHCA) passed by the House last month, and the Senate’s current efforts, pose a threat to this coverage. The AHCA would phase out the ACA’s enhanced funding for the Medicaid expansion and cap federal Medicaid spending. Under the bill, California stands to lose $24 billion by 2027. It would face painful cuts to eligibility or benefits — or both.

This is particularly alarming amid an opioid epidemic in which certain California counties have overdose death rates among the highest in the nation.

Repeal of the ACA wouldn’t affect only people who receive Medicaid. The House bill would allow states to waive “essential health benefits” requirements, allowing insurers to exclude coverage for a variety of services or to charge higher premiums if those services are included, according to a report from the Urban Institute. Before the ACA was enacted, people who purchased their own insurance and those covered in small businesses were at great risk of having mental health disorders excluded from coverage. Coverage of behavioral health services in the individual market was extremely limited: One-third of people had no coverage for SUD, and nearly 20% had no mental health coverage. The coverage that did exist was typically very limited.

Percentage of Californians who say they believe their insurance covers treatment for behavioral health conditions, by insurance type

The survey shows that not only do people value mental health and SUD coverage in the abstract, they’re also aware that they have it and they’re ready to use it. CHCF has been tracking consumer understanding of behavioral health coverage since the ACA first took effect. In today’s poll, two in three respondents said their health plans covered mental health and SUD services, a 5 percentage-point increase from a similar CHCF-sponsored poll in 2014. Only 47% of people with Medi-Cal, however, said that they were covered for mental health treatment even though these services are in fact covered by the program.

The survey also found that people were open to seeking behavioral health treatment if needed (66% for a mental health condition, 65% for drug use problems). Twenty-two percent reported that they or a family member had sought treatment for a mental health condition within the last year.

Stigma and access gaps remain, but this survey shows that Californians know recovery happens and treatment works — and they care about maintaining access to these vital services.

This poll was the second of two conducted by Berkeley IGS on hehalf of CHCF. The first poll surveyed Californians on their views of the Affordable Care Act and Medi-Cal. Learn more about both polls. Visit CHCF’s ACA Repeal Resource page for emerging analysis of the potential impact of the AHCA on California.

More from the CHCF Blog