California HealthCare Foundation – Supporting ideas and innovations to improve health care for all Californians.

Estimating the Compliance Costs for California SB 1953

Charles Meade, Jonathan Kulick, and Richard Hillestad of RAND Corporation

This report examines the costs and consequences of SB 1953, California’s legislation for seismic safety that will require about half of California’s hospital buildings to be retrofitted, reconstructed, or closed over the next 28 years.

  • Print
  • Downloads
  • This is archived content; for historical reference only.
April 2002

To meet the requirements of California state law, hospitals are considering large construction programs to increase the seismic strength of their facilities. Researchers from the RAND Corporation analyzed the costs and decision-making for these activities, which will produce dramatic changes in the California hospital infrastructure.

The research found that approximately 50% of California's hospital buildings will be retrofitted, reconstructed, or closed over the next 28 years to meet the requirements of California Senate Bill 1953 (SB 1953), the state's legislative framework for hospital seismic safety. Over the same period, approximately 75% of the buildings will undergo nonstructural renovations to improve operational capabilities following a large earthquake. Viewed in its entirety, the scale of this construction program will be unprecedented for California hospitals, and the costs will be correspondingly large. The researchers estimate that the total expenditures by hospitals may be as large as $41.7 billion.

To inform the current policy debate on hospital seismic safety, this report identifies SB 1953 compliance costs, which are a subset of the total construction expenditures. Although SB 1953 pertains to seismic safety, it should trigger health policy and business questions because the law will bring significant changes to California's hospitals. Viewed from another perspective, SB 1953 has motivated the first large-scale examination of California's hospital infrastructure.

The full report can be found under Document Downloads below.